Honest take
GymNation Downtown Dubai runs 24/7 — The Burj Club doesn't. GymNation Downtown Dubai has the broader class schedule. The Burj Club has pool access — GymNation Downtown Dubai doesn't. They sit in different tiers — GymNation Downtown Dubai is budget, The Burj Club is ultra — so they suit different budgets.
Pick GymNation Downtown Dubai if free parking.
Pick The Burj Club if polished member experience.
Affiliate disclosure: The "Visit" links above are affiliate links where partnerships exist. Pricing and listings are based on real research, not commission rate.